Wilson and Alroy's Record Reviews We listen to the lousy records so you won't have to.

 Main page 

 New additions 

 Pop: 00s  90s 80s 70s 60s 50s

 Latin/Jazz 

 Top 20: DBW JA 

 E-mail 

Laura Nyro


Reviewed on this page:
More Than A New Discovery - Eli And The Thirteenth Confession - New York Tendaberry - Christmas and the Beads of Sweat - Gonna Take A Miracle - Smile - Season Of Light - Nested - Live At The Bottom Line - Walk The Dog And Light The Light


Bronx-born Laura Nyro was a jazz-poet white soul singer-songwriter years before Joni Mitchell and Rickie Lee Jones. She soon became known as a hit songwriter, as her tunes became hits for Peter, Paul and Mary, the Fifth Dimension, and others. After a traumatic appearance at Monterey Pop in 1967, Nyro recovered with a series of idiosyncratic, allusive, almost stream-of-consciousness LPs that were surprisingly successful. But she spent most of the next thirty years in retirement before her death in April of 1997, and her reputation is mostly built on what she accomplished in her late teens and early twenties. Nyro may be more noteworthy as a trailblazer than a composer or performer - despite her distinctive vocal style and soul-baring lyrics, I don't find her songs communicate to me anything like Mitchell or Jones do, partly because she can be so damn hard to understand.

There's a marvelous fan site with just about anything you could ask for about Nyro, from discography to photos to interviews. (DBW)


More Than A New Discovery (1966)
She already had her whole act figured out when she recorded this debut at the age of 19. She has a good if conventional ear for melody ("Wedding Bell Blues," later a hit for the Fifth Dimension), and blends full-blown pop arrangements with blues ("California Shoeshine Boys") and gospel ("And When I Die") influences. The lyrics are more disciplined and linear than on her other 60s releases, but they're not necessarily more interesting: "Flim Flam Man" is amusing but hardly profound, while "Billy's Blues" is so vague it's hardly saying anything at all. But the arrangements (by Herb Bernstein) aren't as intrusive as Eli's, and if you like Nyro at all you'll want to hear this. This record is best known as The First Songs, the title used by Columbia when it reissued the album after her later records became hits. (DBW)

Eli and the Thirteenth Confession (1968)
Her breakthrough album, containing "Stoned Soul Picnic" (a big hit for the Fifth Dimension), an ode to alcohol and self-deception ("Sweet Blindness"), meditations on Catholic guilt and desire ("December's Boudoir"), and plenty of tunes I don't understand at all ("Eli's Comin," "The Confession," "Once It Was Alright Now (Farmer Joe)"). Oh, and a love song which may or may not be about her cat ("Timer"). Arrangements by former Four Season Charlie Calello rely heavily on late 60s pop bombast ("Luckie," "Lu"), and the record works best when maximum space is left for her intense, soulful piano and vocals ("Poverty Train," "Lonely Women"). (DBW)

New York Tendaberry (1969)
Nyro did the arrangements this time, which mostly means just vocal and piano, with orchestral colors used only for occasional effect. With the attention solidly focused on Nyro, she pours out lots of difficult, moody, unstructured compositions which are sometimes arresting ("Captain For Dark Mornings," "Captain Saint Lucifer"), but more often the record seems like one long disjointed rant ("Tom Cat goodbye"). Her limited approach to piano, relying exclusively on dramatic block chords, contributes to the record's insular sound. There's no concession to pop at all - no catchy refrains or melodic hooks - and it won't work as background music: you have to listen to it seriously or not at all. It's perhaps her best-loved album by fans, though, because it's Nyro at her purest. She produced with Roy Halee. (DBW)

Christmas And The Beads Of Sweat (1970)
Much as it goes against my grain to admit this, I think turning over the production reins to Arif Mardin and Felix Cavaliere helped: the arrangements are fleshed-out ("Brown Earth") and creative ("Upstairs By A Chinese Lamp"), but far subtler than Calello's or Bernstein's on the first two albums. Much of the credit goes to the incredible supporting cast: David Hood & Roger Hawkins, Chuck Rainey & Cornell Dupree, Duane Allman, Richard Davis, even Alice Coltrane on harp. Add Nyro's piano (more technically advanced than on previous releases), edgy vocals and moody compositions, and the result is a smooth, satisfyingly complex ride that presages the pop-fusion of the mid-Seventies, without the overreaching and awkwardness of her earlier work. But instead of taking the world by storm, she disappeared, not releasing another album of original tunes for six years, and the explanation may be found in the deep melancholy expressed here: "Been On A Train," an unforgettable portrait of addiction and suicide, and the list of social ills "Christmas In My Soul" are only the most obvious examples. So don't look here for quick uplift - Nyro's more about asking questions ("Map To The Treasure") than providing solutions - but it's so musical it isn't depressing either. (And as usual, I often have no idea what she's talking about: "Beads of Sweat," for example.) The cover of Carole King's "Up On The Roof" is so similar to King's own style it seems superfluous; all the other tunes are Nyro's. (DBW)

Gonna Take A Miracle (1971)
A whole album of early 60s soul/R&B covers, with Labelle featured on backing vocals. Apparently a heartfelt homage to her influences, though the fact that she didn't release any new compositions for another half-decade suggests that writer's block was an important factor. The arrangements are pretty faithful, and most of the tunes are very familiar ("Spanish Harlem"; Teddy Randazzo's title track), making the whole project seem like a desperate bid for commercial success. Her voice is in fine form, but doesn't shed any light on tunes like "You've Really Got A Hold On Me" or "Jimmy Mack" (about half the selections are Motown). Produced by Gamble and Huff, and most of the players would soon form the Philly International house band - Norman Harris and Roland Chambers (guitar), Ronnie Baker (bass), Vince Montana (percussion) - while Nydia Mata makes her first of many appearances on percussion. (DBW)

Smile (1976)
No, this isn't her Beach Boys tribute. Nyro's first record in years, and right away she lets you know she's changed, with a sweet song of desire that seems intended for another woman ("Sexy Mama," by Ray, Goodman and Robinson, the only song on the record she didn't write). The good news is, Nyro sounds great, the melodies are strong, and the arrangements are solid, sometimes fascinating (the end of "Smile" is a trio for bass and two kotos). The less good news is, several of the songs focusing on political and environmental issues are didactic: "The Cat-Song" is too precious, and "Money" is just no fun, though Michael Brecker contributes an unexpected John Coltrane impression. Also, the record's very short, with just eight tracks mostly running three or four minutes. Aside from Mata, Richard Davis and the Breckers, there are a ton of studio cats like Bob Babbit, Alan Schwartzberg & Jeff Mironov (all fresh from defiling Jimi Hendrix's legacy in 1975), Chris Parker and Will Lee. Nyro brought Callelo back as co-producer, but there's no trace of the orchestration of Eli. (DBW)

Season Of Light (1977)
By the time of this live recording, Nyro was following the school of singer-songwriters she had been leading. In particular, the laid-back fusiony band that reinterprets her 60s material brings to mind Joni Mitchell's work with the LA Express, but where Miles of Aisles breathed life into Mitchell's acoustic material, the unimaginative arrangements here crush Nyro's idiosyncratic spark. Of course, the songs are so good this is still by and large an enjoyable listen, made more interesting by the inclusion of some later, less well known material: "Upstairs By A Chinese Lamp," "When I Was A Freeport (And You Were The Main Drag)." There are also two tunes from Smile, but they're perhaps the least interesting songs from that record: "The Cat-Song" and "Money." The band includes John Tropea (guitar), Michael Mainieri (keyboards, though Nyro holds down piano herself), Andy Newmark (drums), Nydia Mata and Carter Collins (percussion), and Ellen Seeling, Jeff King and Jeanie Fineberg on horns. There was a lengthier CD import released ten years later that includes several bonus cuts and restores some fade-out jams; it's more of the same, basically, and is worth another half-star but don't pay through the nose for it. (DBW)

Nested (1978)
Nyro produced with Roscoe Harring, and went with a very mellow, stripped-down sound. A couple of tracks feature only Nyro singing and playing piano ("Crazy Love"), but without the enthusiasm or unpredictability of her better work, it gets dull. The full-band tunes aren't much more energetic: most of "Mr. Blue" is a lengthy spoken intro over simple folk-rock changes; "The Nest" drags under its heavy weight of Meaning. The lyrics are heartfelt but a bit obvious ("Child In A Universe") - more than anything she sounds like a depressed version of Cris Williamson. Fortunately, there are enough pleasant, easygoing melodic tunes ("American Dreamer," "Light," "The Sweet Sky" with lovely backing vocals) to keep you from falling asleep. Players include Lee and Mata again, with Andy Newmark on drums, John Sebastian on harmonica, and Cavaliere. (DBW)

Mother's Spiritual (1984)
Another return after a long layoff, and she took on environmental and feminist concerns in earnest. The band includes the improbably-named combo of Lisa Sunshine (bass) and Terry Silverlight (drums), plus John Bristo (guitar), Mata, and guest Todd Rundgren on synth. Produced by Nyro. (DBW)

Live At The Bottom Line (1989)
Nyro sounds in high spirits during this live performance, and from the opening "The Confession," there's a surprising emphasis on punchy rock and roll grooves. (Though one of her old singalong standbys, "And When I Die," gets a toned-down, moody treatment that's more affecting than the original.) Two new tracks, "Roll Of The Ocean" and "Japanese Restaurant Song," are masterful in integrating her focus on earth and family with innovative, propulsive arrangements - mature music in the best sense. There's very little repetition of tracks from Season Of Light, but the approach here is so different - straightforward, vigorous, without jazz pretensions - the older material sounds fresh anyway. The slower piano numbers are less affecting, though, with rambling melodies ("Park Song," "Broken Rainbow," "Companion"). The band is Jimmy Vivino (guitar), Frank Pagano (drums), David Wofford (bass), Diane Wilson (harmony) and Mata, and they all provide solid support without drawing too much attention to themselves. Produced by Nyro, co-produced by Vivino. If you want to hear live Nyro - or if you're interested in her at all - this is a good buy. (DBW)

Walk The Dog And Light The Light (1993)
Continuing the energetic pop-based approach of Bottom Line, Nyro wrote everything except for the occasional tribute ("Dedicated To The One I Love"). The rhythm section is Bernard Purdie (drums) and Freddie Washington (bass), while other musicians include the Breckers and Michael Landau - as you'd expect from that cast, the backing is well manicured and radio-ready ("A Woman Of The World") and predictable ("A Woman Of The World"). Likewise, the tunes are pleasant ("Oh Yeah Maybe Baby (The Heebie Jeebies)") but generally lack the intensely personal sensibility she brought to so much of her work, even when the lyrics are explicitly political ("Louise's Church"). The exceptions are the unpredictable but rambling "Lite A Flame (The Animal Rights Song)" and a dispirited but moving remake of "Broken Rainbow." Produced by Gary Katz and Nyro; the last album released during her lifetime. (DBW)

Live From Mountain Stage (2000)
Posthumous release of a 1990 concert, with most of the same songs as Live At The Bottom Line. (DBW)

Angel In The Dark (2001)
Another posthumous release, with some covers like "La-La Means I Love You" and "Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow" alongside original material. (DBW)


Surry down.

 Main page 

 New additions 

 Pop: 00s  90s 80s 70s 60s 50s

 Latin/Jazz 

 Top 20: DBW JA 

 E-mail